No ads. No sponsors. Self-funded. Built for you, not advertisers.
Ghost Man Encyclopedia · Charts & trend

What is relative strength compared with the S&P 500?

By Ghost Man Trades · Last reviewed · Education only, not advice

Short answer. Relative strength compares a stock's performance with a benchmark, usually the S&P 500. One method divides the stock's price by the index's price; a rising line means the stock is outperforming. Another subtracts the index's return from the stock's over a set period. It is not the same as RSI, which compares a stock only with its own past.

Relative strength in plain English

A stock that rose 6% sounds good until you learn the market rose 9% over the same months. Relative strength answers the question "compared with what?" It measures whether a stock is doing better or worse than a benchmark, most often the S&P 500, or a fund that tracks it such as SPY.

There are two common ways to measure it:

  • Price relative (ratio line): stock price ÷ benchmark price, plotted over time. A rising line means the stock is outperforming; a falling line means it is lagging. The level of the line doesn't matter, only its direction.
  • Return difference: stock return − benchmark return over the same period, in percentage points. Easy to read in a table.

Don't confuse either with RSI. The Relative Strength Index compares a stock with its own past. Comparative relative strength compares it with something else.

Example (hypothetical numbers).

  • Example Co. goes from $50 to $53 in three months: +6%. The S&P 500 fund goes from $500 to $545: +9%.
  • Return difference: 6% − 9% = −3 percentage points. The stock rose but lagged the market.
  • Price relative: at the start $50 ÷ $500 = 0.1000. At the end $53 ÷ $545 = 0.0972. The ratio fell by (0.0972 ÷ 0.1000 − 1) × 100 ≈ −2.8%, which matches 1.06 ÷ 1.09 − 1.
  • Next quarter the market falls 10% and the stock falls 4%: the stock is 6 points ahead, outperforming in a down market.

Common mistakes

  • Mixing up RS and RSI. Similar names, different measurements.
  • Ignoring dividends. Comparing price-only returns with a total-return index understates high-dividend stocks. Use the same basis for both.
  • Using one period. A stock can lead over one month and lag over six. Check a few horizons.
  • Treating outperformance as safety. A stock falling less than the market still lost money.
  • Chasing leaders blindly. Strong relative strength can reverse quickly, especially after a long run. See mean reversion vs momentum.

How Ghost Man uses this

Relative strength is not part of the Ghost Man buy or take-profit rules, but we use it on the Ghost Report's sector rotation table. It compares the 11 SPDR sector funds with SPY using the return-difference method: each fund's total return (dividends included) minus SPY's, in percentage points, over 21, 63 and 126 trading days, about 1, 3 and 6 months.

The labels follow from that: ahead of SPY over both 3 months and 1 month is "money flowing in," behind over both is "money flowing out." It describes past moves, not a forecast. Our buy signals often come in stocks with weak recent relative strength, because they look for pullbacks to the 4-year average.

Related terms

Learn it step by step in Swing School

Frequently asked questions

Is relative strength the same as RSI?

No. RSI, the Relative Strength Index, compares a stock's own recent gains with its own recent losses. Relative strength compares the stock's performance with something else, such as the S&P 500 or its sector.

Can a stock have strong relative strength while falling?

Yes. If a stock falls 5% while the S&P 500 falls 15%, it has outperformed by 10 percentage points. It is stronger than the market, even though holders lost money.

Which benchmark should I use?

The S&P 500 is the usual choice for large U.S. stocks. Comparing a stock with its own sector fund shows whether it is leading or lagging its peers.

Does strong relative strength predict future gains?

Academic research has found that stocks with strong returns over the past 3 to 12 months have tended to keep outperforming for a while, but the effect is not reliable for any single stock and can reverse sharply.

How do I chart relative strength?

Many charting platforms let you plot one symbol divided by another, for example a stock divided by SPY. A rising line means the stock is outperforming; you can also add a moving average to the ratio line to see its trend.

Sources

We check every definition and formula against these sources. Our own rules come from the Ghost Man scan code that runs this site.

Education only. Education only, not financial advice. Ghost Man Trades is not a registered investment adviser or broker-dealer. Past results, including historical signal records, do not guarantee future results. Trading involves risk of loss. All examples on this page are hypothetical and use made-up numbers to show the math.

All encyclopedia entries · Glossary · Swing School

See it on a live chart

The Ghost Report shows which quality stocks sit near or below their 4-year average right now. Members also get the Ghost Man indicator on their own TradingView charts.

60 days free, no card needed. Then $49/month for founding members, locked in for life. $99/month regular price later.

Start the free 60-day beta