What is the difference between mean reversion and momentum?
By Ghost Man Trades · Last reviewed · Education only, not advice
Momentum in plain English
Momentum says: what has been going up tends to keep going up for a while. A momentum trader buys stocks with strong recent performance, often measured as relative strength against the market, and avoids or sells the laggards. In a widely cited 1993 study, Narasimhan Jegadeesh and Sheridan Titman found that buying past winners and selling past losers generated significant positive returns over three- to twelve-month holding periods, and that part of those gains faded over the following two years.
Mean reversion in plain English
Mean reversion says: prices that have stretched far from their normal level tend to come back toward it. A mean-reversion trader buys after a sharp drop and sells after a sharp rise. Over long horizons, Werner De Bondt and Richard Thaler's 1985 paper "Does the Stock Market Overreact?" reported that stocks that had been the biggest losers over the prior several years went on to beat the prior winners over the following years.
The two don't contradict each other as much as they seem. They tend to show up on different time scales, and many strategies combine them.
Example (hypothetical numbers).
- Stock A is up 40% over 12 months; the market is up 10%. Stock B is down 30%; the market is up 10%.
- Relative to the market: A is +30 points, B is −40 points.
- Momentum trader: buys A, avoids B.
- Mean-reversion trader: looks at B, which trades 25% below its long-term average of $40, at $30 ($30 ÷ $40 − 1).
- If B returns to its $40 average, that is ($40 ÷ $30 − 1) × 100 = +33%. If the business has broken and the "average" falls to $25 over the next few years, the same trade loses money.
Common mistakes
- Mixing time frames. A mean-reversion entry with a momentum holding period, or the reverse, can get the worst of both.
- Assuming the mean is fixed. Moving averages move. A falling average pulls fair value down with it.
- Buying every dip. Dips in declining businesses become value traps.
- Chasing momentum late. Momentum can reverse sharply, especially after long runs.
- Treating research averages as personal outcomes. Academic results describe portfolios of many stocks, before many real-world costs.
How Ghost Man uses this
Ghost Man is mostly a mean-reversion system with a value filter. It buys when a stock's Ghost Wave has fallen to 20 or lower and turns up, with the close no more than 10% above the 4-year average, betting that a quality company stretched to the downside will recover. It takes profit when the Ghost Wave turns down from 80 or higher in the red zone at the top of the 1-year range.
The trade-off shows up in our own results. A pure momentum stock that never pulls back to its 4-year average never gets a Ghost Man buy, so the system can sit out long uptrends. That is why, for metals, simply holding did better than following the signals on our records, and on forex the system doesn't suit the market at all. And with no stop loss, a mean-reversion buy whose "mean" is collapsing can stay open at a large loss.
Related terms
- Relative strength vs the S&P 500 · What is relative strength compared with the S&P 500?
- Overbought vs oversold · What do overbought and oversold mean?
- 200-week moving average · What is the 200-week moving average (the 4-year average)?
- Bollinger Bands · What are Bollinger Bands, and how do you read them?
- Value trap · What is a value trap?
- Swing trading · What is swing trading?
- Stochastic oscillator · How is the stochastic oscillator calculated (%K, %D, fast vs slow)?
Learn it step by step in Swing School
Frequently asked questions
Which works better, momentum or mean reversion?
Neither all the time. Academic studies have found momentum over roughly 3 to 12 months and long-term reversal over several years, but both effects vary by period and market and can fail badly.
Is buying the dip mean reversion?
Yes. Buying because price has fallen below its normal level assumes it will move back toward that level.
Can a strategy use both?
Yes. A common mix is to require a long-term uptrend (momentum) and buy short-term pullbacks within it (mean reversion).
What is the biggest risk of mean reversion?
That the average itself moves. If a business has truly declined, the old average is no longer fair value, and price may not come back.
Is the Ghost Wave a momentum or mean-reversion tool?
It measures momentum on a 0 to 100 scale, but Ghost Man uses it in a mean-reversion way: buying when it turns up from a low reading near the 4-year average, and taking profit when it turns down from a high reading in the red zone.
Sources
We check every definition and formula against these sources. Our own rules come from the Ghost Man scan code that runs this site.
- Jegadeesh and Titman, Returns to Buying Winners and Selling Losers, Journal of Finance 48(1), 1993 (abstract on RePEc)
- De Bondt and Thaler, Does the Stock Market Overreact?, Journal of Finance 40(3), 1985 (citation on RePEc)
- StockCharts ChartSchool: Price Relative / Relative Strength