No ads. No sponsors. Self-funded. Built for you, not advertisers.
Ghost Man Encyclopedia · Risk & testing

What is the difference between win rate and expectancy in trading?

By Ghost Man Trades · Last reviewed · Education only, not advice

Short answer. Win rate is the percentage of trades that make money. Expectancy is the average result per trade with wins and losses both counted: (win rate × average win) − (loss rate × average loss). A strategy can win 90% of the time and still lose money if its few losses are large, so expectancy matters more.

Win rate and expectancy in plain English

Win rate answers "how often?" Out of all your closed trades, what share made money? Ten trades with seven winners is a 70% win rate.

Expectancy answers "how much, on average?" It weighs how often you win by how big the wins are, and how often you lose by how big the losses are. It is the trading version of what statisticians call expected value.

Expectancy per trade = (win rate × average win) − (loss rate × average loss), where loss rate = 1 − win rate and the average loss is written as a positive number. If the answer is positive, the rules made money on average. If it is negative, they lost money no matter how often they "won."

Example (hypothetical numbers): two strategies.

  • Strategy A wins 90% of the time with an average gain of +5%, and loses 10% of the time with an average loss of −60%.
    Expectancy = 0.90 × 5 − 0.10 × 60 = 4.5 − 6.0 = −1.5% per trade. It loses money, despite winning nine trades out of ten.
  • Strategy B wins 40% of the time with an average gain of +20%, and loses 60% of the time with an average loss of −5%.
    Expectancy = 0.40 × 20 − 0.60 × 5 = 8.0 − 3.0 = +5.0% per trade. It loses more often than it wins and still comes out well ahead.
  • Check with 10 trades of $1,000 each for Strategy A: 9 wins × $50 = $450, 1 loss × $600 = −$600. Net: −$150, or −$15 per trade, which is −1.5%.

Strategy A is what many "high win rate" systems look like: they take small profits quickly and let losers run. It feels great for months and then one trade wipes out the gains.

Common mistakes

  • Advertising, or believing, a win rate alone. Always ask for the average win, the average loss and the worst loss.
  • Ignoring open trades. If losing trades are left open and only closed trades are counted, the win rate can look much better than the true picture.
  • Ignoring time. Expectancy is per trade, not per year. Long-held trades tie up money that could be working elsewhere.
  • Too few trades. Expectancy from five trades is mostly luck. It becomes meaningful over many trades.
  • Forgetting costs. Commissions, spreads and slippage come off every trade and can turn a small positive expectancy negative.

How Ghost Man uses this

Every Ghost Man signal record shows the win rate and the average return per closed trade, which is the expectancy per trade for that stock and chart, plus the best and worst trade. We show both because the win rate alone would flatter us.

Here is why. The rules have no stop loss: a trade only closes on a take-profit signal. A losing trade usually stays open, and the records count closed trades only. So a stock's closed-trade win rate can look very high while its current open trade is deep underwater. We list that open trade right next to the record on every stock page so it can't hide. When you read our records, look at the average return, the worst trade and the open trade together, and remember that the records are backtests with survivorship bias and no trading costs.

Related terms

Learn it step by step in Swing School

Frequently asked questions

What is a good win rate for trading?

A win rate means nothing on its own. A 35% win rate can be very profitable when the average win is several times the average loss, and a 90% win rate can lose money when the average loss is much larger than the average win.

How do you calculate trading expectancy?

Multiply the win rate by the average win, multiply the loss rate by the average loss, and subtract the second from the first. With percentages, 40% wins averaging +20% and 60% losses averaging −5% gives 0.4 × 20 − 0.6 × 5 = +5% per trade.

Is average return per trade the same as expectancy?

Yes, when every trade is counted. The average return across all closed trades, winners and losers together, equals the expectancy per trade for those trades.

Why do high win rate strategies feel good but still fail?

Frequent small wins are rewarding, so people stick with strategies that bank small gains and let losers run. One large loss can erase many small wins.

Does expectancy account for how long trades take?

Not by itself. A +5% average trade that takes a year is very different from one that takes a month. Compare results per unit of time, or annualize, before comparing strategies.

Sources

We check every definition and formula against these sources. Our own rules come from the Ghost Man scan code that runs this site.

Education only. Education only, not financial advice. Ghost Man Trades is not a registered investment adviser or broker-dealer. Past results, including historical signal records, do not guarantee future results. Trading involves risk of loss. All examples on this page are hypothetical and use made-up numbers to show the math.

All encyclopedia entries · Glossary · Swing School

See it on a live chart

The Ghost Report shows which quality stocks sit near or below their 4-year average right now. Members also get the Ghost Man indicator on their own TradingView charts.

60 days free, no card needed. Then $49/month for founding members, locked in for life. $99/month regular price later.

Start the free 60-day beta